Indiana appeals court upholds father’s sentence, conviction in daughter’s death

GREENFIELD — The Indiana Court of Appeals has denied Matthew Wagoner’s request to overturn the conviction and sentence he received for murdering his 1-year-old daughter Zoey.

The Greenfield man was found guilty of murder and neglect of a dependent in January and was sentenced to 67 1/2 years in a Department of Correction facility.

He appealed the local court’s ruling earlier this year, and on Monday, the state court issued a ruling upholding the conviction.

“It is challenging to find words that fully capture the heinousness of his actions. As the parent of Z.W., as well as her sole caregiver on the morning of her death, Wagoner held the ultimate position of trust and abused that position in a violent, horrifying fashion,” the court ruling states.

It also rejected his motion for his sentence to be overturned.

“It has often been said that maximum sentences should be reserved for the very worst offenses and the very worst offenders. We do not fault the trial court for finding that this case qualifies,” the ruling states.

Author photo
Samm Quinn is a reporter at the Greenfield Daily Reporter. She can be reached at 317-477-3275 or