Daily Reporter logo

Ex-deputy, sheriff's department named in notice of tort claim

Follow Daily Reporter:

GREENFIELD — Another woman who was once romantically involved with ex-Deputy Scott Roeger is threatening to sue both Roeger and the Hancock County Sheriff’s Department.

Meagan Navarro, the victim in a Hamilton County criminal case filed against Roeger late last year, is asking $700,000 in damages for “mental anguish and suffering,” according to a notice of tort claim.

A notice of tort claim is a legal document filed in advance of a lawsuit.

Navarro of Noblesville dated Roeger briefly last year, according to police reports. Roeger is accused of making threats against the woman and looking up her personal information in a state database in order to intimidate her after they stopped seeing one another.

Roeger, who resigned from the sheriff’s department early this year before a termination hearing, is charged in Hamilton County with official misconduct, a Class D felony, and intimidation, a misdemeanor.

Police officers are prohibited from using state databases for personal reasons.

Navarro’s is the second tort-claim notice filed against Roeger and the county by one of Roeger’s alleged victims in the last month.

Also threatening to sue is Jennifer Wilson-Trattner of McCordsville, Roeger’s ex-girlfriend and the victim in three criminal cases recently filed against the former deputy.

Roeger accepted a plea agreement last week in two of the cases involving Wilson-Trattner, and two additional cases, one involving Wilson-Trattner and one involving Roeger’s ex-wife, were dismissed.

Roeger pleaded guilty to misdemeanor charges of battery and criminal mischief, both relating to domestic disputes with Wilson-Trattner.

Wilson-Trattner is also asking for $700,000, alleging that Roeger and other members of the sheriff’s department, who are not named, conspired to cover Roeger’s “physical violence … and other illegal conduct.”  

Both women are represented by Curtis Johnson of Shelbyville.

Sheriff Mike Shepherd declined to comment.

Roeger declined to comment.

Think your friends should see this? Share it with them!

All content copyright ©2016 Daily Reporter, a publication of AIM Media Indiana unless otherwise noted.
All rights reserved. Click here to read our privacy policy.
Daily Reporter • 22 W. New Road • Greenfield, IN 46140 • (317) 462-5528